DNA 3D Icon - GenomeBeans

Blog Details

How to Choose Between IMGT, Kabat, and Chothia for Antibody Analysis: What Researchers Should Know

Antibody sequence analysis involves more than identifying amino acid residues within the heavy and light chains. Researchers also need to understand how these residues are numbered, aligned, and mapped to functional regions of the antibody.

How To Choose Between IMGT, Kabat, And Chothia For Antibody Analysis: What Researchers Should Know

This becomes particularly important when analysing variable domains, identifying complementarity-determining regions (CDRs), comparing mutations, or interpreting antibody structures.

IMGT, Kabat, and Chothia are three established antibody numbering schemes. Each uses a different approach to assigning residue positions, which can influence how researchers interpret sequence and structural data.

What Are Antibody Numbering Schemes?

Antibodies contain variable domains in their heavy and light chains. These domains consist of framework regions (FRs) and CDRs.

The three CDRs, CDR1, CDR2, and CDR3, contribute to antigen recognition and binding specificity. Framework regions provide the structural support required to maintain the immunoglobulin fold.

Antibody numbering schemes assign standardised position labels to amino acid residues within these variable domains. They account for differences in sequence length, insertions, and deletions, allowing researchers to compare corresponding regions across different antibodies.

However, the schemes differ in how they define residue positions and CDR boundaries.

How Are IMGT, Kabat, and Chothia Different?

1. IMGT Numbering

The IMGT numbering system uses a unified framework for immunoglobulins and T-cell receptors. Its unique numbering for variable domains covers positions 1–128 and is anchored on highly conserved residues (such as Cys23, Trp41 and Cys104), so that equivalent structural positions receive the same number across different sequences.

A key feature is its standardised position assignment, with gaps used to accommodate differences in sequence length. This is most visible in CDR3, where varying loop lengths are handled by leaving positions unoccupied rather than adding insertion labels.

IMGT numbering is particularly useful for:

  • Comparing antibody and T-cell receptor variable domains.
  • Analysing immune repertoire sequencing datasets.
  • Identifying framework and CDR regions using consistent boundaries.
  • Integrating sequence information across immunological studies.

2. Kabat Numbering

Kabat numbering is primarily based on sequence variability. It was developed by examining variations in antibody sequences to identify regions associated with antigen recognition.

Unlike a simple sequential numbering system, Kabat uses insertion labels such as 35A, 35B and 52A to accommodate additional residues at specific positions.

This approach is useful when analysing sequence variation and comparing antibody residues with historical literature that follows Kabat conventions.

However, insertion positions and CDR definitions can make direct comparisons with other numbering systems more complicated.

3. Chothia Numbering

Chothia numbering incorporates structural information, particularly the three-dimensional conformations of antibody loops.

It largely follows Kabat numbering but moves the insertion points in several loops (L1, H1 and H2) to positions that better match the underlying structure. This is especially relevant because antibody loops can differ in length and conformation while retaining similar structural roles.

Chothia numbering is commonly associated with structural antibody analysis, including the study of loop conformations and canonical structures. It can therefore be useful in antibody modelling, structure comparison, and engineering studies.

Other schemes you may encounter

Martin (sometimes called enhanced Chothia) and AHo are two further schemes used mainly in structure-based analysis and antibody engineering. Many numbering tools can convert between these and the three schemes above.

Why Do CDR Boundaries Differ Between Numbering Schemes?

A major difference between antibody numbering systems is how they define the boundaries of CDRs.

For example, commonly used heavy-chain CDR1 definitions include:

  • IMGT: Positions 27–38
  • Kabat: Positions 31–35B
  • Chothia: Positions 26–32

These ranges represent scheme-specific numbering and CDR definitions, not identical amino acid coordinates. The same antibody sequence can therefore receive different CDR assignments depending on the convention used.

IMGT follows a unified numbering framework, Kabat emphasises sequence variability, and Chothia incorporates structural considerations. Understanding these differences is essential when interpreting CDR lengths, mapping residues, and comparing antibody datasets.

How Does Numbering Affect Antibody Analysis?

Consider a study comparing antibody sequences from two datasets, where one follows Kabat numbering and the other uses IMGT.

A residue labelled 35 in one scheme may not correspond directly to residue 35 in another. Insertions, deletions, and differences in CDR definitions can shift the position labels.

Without appropriate numbering conversion, researchers may misinterpret residue-level comparisons or incorrectly map mutations to functional regions.

This can affect several analytical activities:

  • CDR identification: Defining antigen-binding regions consistently across antibody sequences.
  • Mutation mapping: Locating substitutions and insertions relative to corresponding variable-domain positions.
  • Structural analysis: Connecting sequence positions with three-dimensional structures and loop conformations.
  • Antibody engineering: Evaluating changes in CDRs and framework residues during sequence optimisation.
  • Cross-dataset comparison: Integrating antibody sequences generated or annotated using different numbering conventions.

For reliable interpretation, researchers should record the numbering scheme used and convert sequences before comparing residue-level results.

How Are Computational Tools Improving Antibody Numbering?

Antibody numbering tools automate residue assignment and support conversion between established numbering conventions.

Earlier tools such as ANARCI use sequence alignment against reference Hidden Markov Models (HMMs) to identify and number antibody variable domains.

ANARCII takes a different approach. It uses a sequence-to-sequence language model to perform antigen receptor numbering without requiring a separate alignment step.

A 2026 research study describes a model trained on more than 160 million antibody heavy- and light-chain sequences. ANARCII generates IMGT numbering and supports conversion into schemes including Kabat, Chothia, Martin, and AHo.

The study also reports improved consistency, robustness to truncated sequences, and generalisation to previously unseen species.

These developments can help researchers process large antibody sequence datasets more efficiently while maintaining consistent residue annotation.

Which Numbering Scheme Should Researchers Choose?

The appropriate numbering scheme depends on the research objective, dataset requirements, and downstream analysis.

Scheme Best suited for
IMGT Standardised antibody and T-cell receptor analysis, immune repertoire studies, and consistent sequence comparisons
Kabat Reproducing earlier studies, analysing Kabat-defined CDRs, and comparing results with historical antibody literature
Chothia Structural studies where antibody loop conformations and canonical structures are important

Researchers should also consider whether their downstream tools expect a specific numbering convention. Using one scheme consistently, or applying a validated conversion method, helps maintain compatibility across analytical workflows.

Making Antibody Analysis More Consistent

Antibody numbering is not simply a way to label amino acid residues. It provides the positional framework needed to interpret variable domains, identify CDRs, map mutations, and connect sequence information with antibody structure.

Understanding the differences between IMGT, Kabat, and Chothia helps researchers select an appropriate convention and avoid inconsistencies during sequence and structural analysis.

At GenomeBeans, researchers can explore bioinformatics solutions and research support for analysing complex biological datasets. Consistent analytical workflows are an important part of generating reliable and interpretable research results.

References

  1. Zhu et al. (2025). Antibody numbering schemes: advances, comparisons and tools for antibody engineering. Protein Engineering, Design and Selection, Volume 38. DOI: 10.1093/protein/gzaf005.
  2. Greenshields-Watson et al. (2026). ANARCII enables alignment-free antigen receptor numbering using a generalised language model. Communications Biology, 9, Article 1085. DOI: 10.1038/s42003-026-10186-z.